- Joined
- Aug 25, 2007
- Messages
- 2,007
- Points
- 63
Yeah, I have seen a lot of people decanning their diodes so I felt the need to let everyone know the risks to the diode. If you see a continued drop in power from the windowless diode, could you give me a rough estimate of time on and the power drop? I only did a test with a diode in open air with no lens to block it to degrade it purposefully. It'd be interesting to see how well these modules seal the diode from the outside world.
One problem though, the paper you sent (thank you for sending, BTW) is only talking about UNCOATED facets degrading from oxidation in air. I haven't inspected an 8x or 12x in a microscope, but at least to my eyes under a 'scope, the PHR violet diode looks like it has facet coatings, and I pretty much guarantee the 8x diodes have facet coatings as well. Those facet coatings prevent any oxidation of the facet surface, so I don't think oxidizing atmosphere is going to be degrading the semiconductor surface. Have you looked at the PHR that degraded to see if it has facet coatings? If it does, then facet oxidation is not what degraded it.
Does anyone have a microscope under which they can inspect to see if the other diodes indeed have facet coatings? Especially with the ones at high power, I'd almost guarantee they do, but it's worth looking.
(BTW, for those who might not know such things, how to tell if it has a facet coating: Looking at the facet in a microscope and moving it around, you should see an even color at certain angles of light. If you see a color, there's a coating there. If there's no color, there's no coating.
When I look at the front facet of a PHR diode, I see an even blue color over the whole facet. Blue makes sense, as an HR coating for a violet or blue laser should reflect violet or blue light. Since HR coatings like DBRs have a very wide HR area, it makes sense that a violet HR coating could be a little off-center and look blue, and vice-versa, as coatings on surfaces that small are not trivial to reproduce consistently.)