- Joined
- Sep 12, 2007
- Messages
- 9,399
- Points
- 113
stand in a dark room filled with smoke and scan 40mw of 635 and 200mw of 660. im pretty sure i know which one would look brighter.
but hey thats just my view
Yes, the 660 should look brighter. Like I said, 40mW of 635 is only as bright as about 130mW of 660. So 200mW of 660 will surely be brighter than 40mW of 635.
what computer programs say and what you see in real life are very different
Yes, Andy's word is infallible.
I (and the light industry standard) say it's equal to ~130mW and you say it's 80mW of 660. But using the square root relationship between power and brightness, That's only a brightness difference of 27%. There's also the tolerance of laser diodes to consider. The 635nm laser I have is actually 640nm, which lowers the visibility to ~110mW of 660nm equivalent, and the difference between your prediction and my prediction is lowered further to only 20% difference in perceived brightness. If the 660 were also being cooled and running at 655nm, your prediction and mine would actually match. You say they are "very different" when they are in fact almost the same.
The CIE tables are not computer programs. They contain actual measurements of the eye response curve.