POLL: Pls help me to decide -which picture is better for you-

[IsaacT]

The other thing I would try is to put everything else except the old lady in color, but to gradually desaturate the red sleeve the closer it gets to the cigarette. This I think would give it a look of the cigarette almost infecting the vibrancy of life or corrupting it. If you are able to you might make a few small streaks of desaturation where the lady is sitting to show it infecting her life.

 

[Tmack]

The gift of a luxury from someone who has no luxury, to someone who thinks nothing of it. She's giving a piece of her limited pleasure, to someone who is much more well off than herself. Man could get a thousand meanings. What a great photo.
The artist should depict it how he sees it. And from the title, it would seem only the cigarette should have color...... Maybe......

 

[DJNY]

Yes, I agree. In the end it depends in what the creator is interpreting into the scene

Gonna think about iit again and play with the colors then. What I don´t like is to create a photomontage.