- Joined
- Jul 10, 2015
- Messages
- 9,959
- Points
- 113
The idea that sound energy would not be created simply because no one is there to hear it is ridiculous, now if you want to debate the literal definition of ( a noise ) being sound that one can hear then you can argue the definition of a word, but sound energy would be made by a falling tree regardless of anyone being within earshot or not.
It's like saying if a deft person saw a tree fall with no one else around would it make a sound ?
How about if a blind person heard a tree fall with no one else around, would there really be a falling tree if no one could see it ?
If a blind person turns on a light switch alone in a closet will the bulb fail to produce any light, could electrons flow through the filament without photons being emitted if no one can see it ?
Here's the rub: Why would the MATRIX make a tree fall without sound just because no one was there to hear it ? Why would the MATRIX make a tree fall at all if no one was there to see it, the idea that gravity would work without anyone being there to see it but sound would not is silly, if the boogie man, I mean MATRIX is going to skip the sound then why not skip the falling tree as well, after all no one is there to see or hear it
It's like saying if a deft person saw a tree fall with no one else around would it make a sound ?
How about if a blind person heard a tree fall with no one else around, would there really be a falling tree if no one could see it ?
If a blind person turns on a light switch alone in a closet will the bulb fail to produce any light, could electrons flow through the filament without photons being emitted if no one can see it ?
Here's the rub: Why would the MATRIX make a tree fall without sound just because no one was there to hear it ? Why would the MATRIX make a tree fall at all if no one was there to see it, the idea that gravity would work without anyone being there to see it but sound would not is silly, if the boogie man, I mean MATRIX is going to skip the sound then why not skip the falling tree as well, after all no one is there to see or hear it
Last edited: