I only have the WL goggles that came with the laser and from what I've heard, they aren't sufficient for protection, so I'll be avoiding your suggestion until I get some new goggles

I could try a small amount of teflon tape though. I'll give that a shot right now and post back with my results.
EDIT: Once I pulled the lens out to put some teflon tape around it, I heard a clicking noise. On the back side of the lens was another screw tightening thingy and that part was lose. I got some tweezers out and tightened it up and the problem is solved. I avoided the teflon tape because when I fix things, I like to try one thing at a time to narrow it down. The first thing I tried worked. Thanks for the tip Prototype... Image below is what I tightened up.