@ Flutterpie
Don't underestimate your native Ohio fishes. I've kept everything from oscars, tetras, archer fish, even a cuvier's bichir. All amazing and wonderful species, but my favorite is keeping native fishes. The hunt and thrill of catching and keeping them, plus you might be surprised at how colorful they can be. IE - I've kept these two fish you should have near you, an orangethroat darter and a southern redbelly dace, striking colors for a fish you can find in a small muddy creek.