Question for the firearms afficianados out there.

[Trevor]

Need some help. I'll be hiking solo this summer in the appalachian region doing camera trapping to track animal populations. The key here is solo. In bear country.

In all of my years of scouting/camp/etc. I've only run across a couple black bears, who were far more afraid of me than I was of them. Though I still feel like the more responsible thing would be to be able to defend myself.

Which brings up my question - what should I be looking into? A friend of mine was talking about a .44 magnum, but my brother encouraged me to run hollow points through a .45 instead, so as to not be using a revolver.

I'm going to be carrying a pack with camera trapping gear, my own camera gear, and food, so I don't think a shotgun is terribly feasible.

If anyone experienced in this sort of thing has any pearls of wisdom to offer, I would love to hear them.

Trevor

 

[RA_pierce]

I can't say what firearm will stop a bear but, as you may already be aware, the best way to avoid bears is to make a lot of noise while hiking (whistling or the like) and to store and eat food several hundred feet away from your campsite.

I would contact the trail/park ranger station and ask them what they recommend.

BTW it sounds like a fun project. I love hiking.

 

[pakrat57]

If you have to use a handgun, between the two you're looking at I'd go with the 44 mag. The 44 can have 2 to as much as three times the energy per round as a 45 auto, that more than makes up for the slight edge in capacity of the auto. And besides, as reliable as modern semi autos are, if you have a round that doesn't go bang, you don't have to rack the slide on a revolver, you just keep squeezing the trigger. That's the way I see it anyhow. Of course if you can, I'd go with something bigger like a 454 casull or something along those lines.

Jim

 

[LEDSanders]

Get a can of bear spray, & a .454 Casull Revolver
no need to play with death and dismemberment.
Ruger Super RedHawk Alaskan .454 Casull Revolver - YouTube

 

[Trevor]

I can't say what firearm will stop a bear but, as you may already be aware, the best way to avoid bears is to make a lot of noise while hiking (whistling or the like) and to store and eat food several hundred feet away from your campsite.

I would contact the trail/park ranger station and ask them what they recommend.

BTW it sounds like a fun project. I love hiking.

Yeah, I definitely plan on talking to the professor in charge of this project about what to do here. And I definitely would rather avoid bears.

Basically I'm getting research credit and a stipend to play in the woods for ten weeks. I'll be doing a lot of data collection and crunching, but I'm a fairly technical person so fortunately that won't take long. But along the way I'll be leveraging my new 1DX (if Canon ever ships it...) to build my portfolio as a landscape and wildlife photographer.

I'm really, really excited.

If you have to use a handgun, between the two you're looking at I'd go with the 44 mag. The 44 can have 2 to as much as three times the energy per round as a 45 auto, that more than makes up for the slight edge in capacity of the auto. And besides, as reliable as modern semi autos are, if you have a round that doesn't go bang, you don't have to rack the slide on a revolver, you just keep squeezing the trigger. That's the way I see it anyhow. Of course if you can, I'd go with something bigger like a 454 casull or something along those lines.

Jim

Really useful info here, thanks. Very helpful. I hadn't thought about the idea of a round not going off... definitely something to consider when this is a gun I'm potentially going to need to use while under duress (SHIT, ANGRY BEAR!). I was thinking that running 45 hollow points might help to make up for the loss of kinetic energy by going for a 45 instead of a 44 mag?

The only thing that concerns me with a 44 magnum is that recoil is a bit of a bear (har har). Fortunately, I'll have about three weeks between when my exams end and when the project starts, so that I can get fully acquainted with whatever I decide to go with.

no need to play with death and dismemberment.

My thoughts exactly...

Trevor

 

[pakrat57]

The only thing that concerns me with a 44 magnum is that recoil is a bit of a bear (har har). Fortunately, I'll have about three weeks between when my exams end and when the project starts, so that I can get fully acquainted with whatever I decide to go with.

Trevor

You definitely need to practice a lot. If you haven't handled handguns much, you should find someone to coach you and go through basic safety with you. Three weeks isn't much time to get familiar with a tool that your life may depend on. And as far as the recoil, you can start out with light loads and work you way up to the more powerful rounds. Like I and LED also mentioned, the 454 casull would be even better, but it would also have more recoil.

Jim

 

[Trevor]

You definitely need to practice a lot. If you haven't handled handguns much, you should find someone to coach you and go through basic safety with you. Three weeks isn't much time to get familiar with a tool that your life may depend on. And as far as the recoil, you can start out with light loads and work you way up to the more powerful rounds. Like I and LED also mentioned, the 454 casull would be even better, but it would also have more recoil.

Jim

I'd consider myself pretty proficient with my brother's Sig P226, but to be fair that's only 9mm. So, I've worked with handguns, but not as much as I'd like to have.

To be fair, I do go to school in southwest Virginia, so finding someplace to shoot (so as to get a jump on practice) won't be a problem at all. I'll start hunting around tomorrow, actually.

Thanks.

Trevor

 

[jcranmer]

Trevor, My go to handgun is always going to be a revolver. They are seriously easy to shoot and take care of. Also if you think about it, the last thing you want is complicated if you have a bear charging at you. It will hold fewer rounds, but if you get to round 5 or 6 and it's still coming at you, you have much bigger issues to worry about.

You just can't beat point and pull the trigger.

I assume with a bear you want as big a round as possible. I might be tempted to look at a Tarus Judge. It's a revolver that takes both .45s and 410 shotgun rounds. It's one of the next handguns I want to get.

Taurus International Manufacturing Inc - The Judge

No idea if that's really big enough to take out a bear though. Also you might want to check the laws in the areas you are going to be in. Some parks have more strict regulations on what you can bring in as far as weapons or at carry conceiled.

 

[Trevor]

if you get to round 5 or 6 and it's still coming at you, you have much bigger issues to worry about.

Yeah. At that point I prettymuch deserve to die...

You're actually the second person that's pointed me in the direction of something that will run .45 and .410... I'll give those a good look when I'm a bit more awake than I am now.

I was looking up Virginia gun laws tonight and I discovered they're really lax. Like, go-out-and-buy-a-handgun-and-do-nothing-else lax. I'll be consulting my professor on specific regulations for where I'll me.

Trevor

 

[RA_pierce]

Yeah, I definitely plan on talking to the professor in charge of this project about what to do here. And I definitely would rather avoid bears.

Basically I'm getting research credit and a stipend to play in the woods for ten weeks. I'll be doing a lot of data collection and crunching, but I'm a fairly technical person so fortunately that won't take long. But along the way I'll be leveraging my new 1DX (if Canon ever ships it...) to build my portfolio as a landscape and wildlife photographer.

I'm really, really excited.

Ugh... I wish I could afford the 1DX. Right now I'm trying to collect a good array of lenses before I get a new camera.

I'd love to see some photos when you get back. I've always wanted to hike the Appalachian trail. It's just so far away from CA. I plan on visiting the Sierras this summer. Wildlife and landscape photography is something I am trying to practice as well.
Nothing is more peaceful than spending some time in the wilderness.
I'm jealous... it sounds like a really fun project. What is your major?

 

[Tonga]

Trevor, the .44 Mag would be the minimum safe level of power I would go with. Forget about the .45 (ACP, I assume is what your brother is talking about) this will just piss off a bear, even a small black bear can kill you if it decides to! If I really thought I was going to come across a bear and I tend to be safer than sorry I would be looking at the .500 S&W Magnum. But you need to be familiar with whatever you decide to carry, you need to be able to deploy it very quickly and try to not miss it because you won't be reloading during a charge!

 

[jcranmer]

I thought about that .500 as well. I've never shot one but I bet it has a heck of a recoil. Might be hard to get a few shots off quickly if it's jumping around after every shot. On the other had its big enough that it might only take one shot. .

 

[Trevor]

Ugh... I wish I could afford the 1DX. Right now I'm trying to collect a good array of lenses before I get a new camera.

I'd love to see some photos when you get back. I've always wanted to hike the Appalachian trail. It's just so far away from CA. I plan on visiting the Sierras this summer. Wildlife and landscape photography is something I am trying to practice as well.
Nothing is more peaceful than spending some time in the wilderness.
I'm jealous... it sounds like a really fun project. What is your major?

I'm in business information technology, but one of my major loves is embedded systems design - so I'm BIT with a whole lot of engineering thrown in the mix.

There's a minor here in interdisciplinary science and engineering, eloquently called "Scieneering." Science-type majors who take it delve into the engineering discipline, whereas the engineering-types delve into the life sciences. This research is part of me getting the minor.

I've been working my ass off for months now, so as to get rid of my Nikon gear and pick up a 1DX, 16-35/2.8L, and 70-200/2.8L. With any luck I'll have a 400 2.8 by the time next semester and sideline-football-shooting start again. Hokie football!

Trevor, the .44 Mag would be the minimum safe level of power I would go with. Forget about the .45 (ACP, I assume is what your brother is talking about) this will just piss off a bear, even a small black bear can kill you if it decides to! If I really thought I was going to come across a bear and I tend to be safer than sorry I would be looking at the .500 S&W Magnum. But you need to be familiar with whatever you decide to carry, you need to be able to deploy it very quickly and try to not miss it because you won't be reloading during a charge!

Okay - I think a friend of mine has a .44 mag, I'll see if I can make it out to the range to see how it goes.

Trevor

 

[Tonga]

I thought about that .500 as well. I've never shot one but I bet it has a heck of a recoil. Might be hard to get a few shots off quickly if it's jumping around after every shot. On the other had its big enough that it might only take one shot. .

Yeah, you are right about that! You would have to be used to the weapon for sure. Hey, I just thought about something else that could kill a black bear and that's a 5.56mm. Sig makes a pistol that you could have 30 rounds ready to use. The 5.56mm is small but very destructive.
I'm not sure if the 5.56mm would be legal to use for black bear in that region or any other for that matter:thinking:.

 

[DarkSide]

Your correct in saying a bear will be equally as frightened as you if you were to cross paths. The black bears native instinct
would be to attack, if threatened. OR he's starving and you are the appetizer. Not sure if any of the folks here have seen a fully grown male black bear but i can say with little doubt a projectile from any handgun on this planet cant create enough velocity to stop a pissed off charging black bear. That said i suggest you lighten your load and bring a proper long gun that will give you a fair chance against mother nature. I would seriously consider a long barrel 12 gauge with 6-8 rounds and a small 4 round clip. And don't go cheap on the ammo , its key when you need to remove as much flesh as necessary to disable this size of target. I would go with Black Hills double 00 shot staggered with lead Sabot Slugs. If your not the best shot stagger in a few incendiary rounds ( they scatter and will burn most any material).

Now you can pack a pistol like some of the folks here suggest but i would take that pistol and shoot small game or beer cans. If your spending time where you say and your cooking, carrying, or eating food outdoors and a black bear catches a smell from 10-15 miles and hunts you ? With some luck a few surgically placed rounds should stop dead or make Mr bear look for another food source.

Good luck and talk to locals when you arrive.

 

[Ghostchrome]

Go big. The last thing you're going to be worrying about is recoil when a freaking bear is about to chew your head off.

Seriously though, best to check on a hunter's forum for this type of thing.