Should all manually given reputation boosts be removed?

c0ldshadow · May 23, 2010

should all manually given reputation boosts be removed? in the last week i received 4 messages saying that ppl think it would be good to reset this

all "natural" reputation would remain, e.g. someone giving reputation feedback for a post in a thread. none of that would be reset.

please no fighting about this, just post what u think about the situation

i am personally leaning towards yes since technically it is fair that all natural reputation remains.

lasersbee · May 23, 2010

:thinking: 4 out of Members: 10,940

Jerry

daguin · May 23, 2010

A gift, once given (deservedly or undeservedly) , becomes the property of the recipient.

Peace,
dave

charliebruce · May 23, 2010

I think it works fine as it is, to be honest - nobody's rep particularly stands out to me as too high for what they've contributed on here.

lasersbee · May 23, 2010

daguin said:
A gift, once given (deservedly or undeservedly) , becomes the property of the recipient.

Peace,
dave

I agree... as stated in PM...
Dave just has the ability to state my thoughts with less wording...:beer:

Jerry

mfo · May 23, 2010

lasersbee said:
:thinking: 4 out of Members: 10,940

Jerry

daguin said:
A gift, once given (deservedly or undeservedly) , becomes the property of the recipient.

Peace,
dave

QFT.

Plus, didn't we have this discussion a few months ago? Leave the rep alone please

SpikeD · May 23, 2010

Reputation points here mean nothing, which is why I didn't even bother asking to get back my old account with 140-something rep power when someone messed with it.
Personally I think the whole rep system should be removed so we don't need to have this pointless discussion over and over, and to avoid petty "reputation battles". IMO, all it does is encourage more drama.
Remove it, keep it, change part of it - I don't really care.

Seb

lasersbee · May 23, 2010

You OK Seb... :thinking:
You sound depressed...
Hope everything is fine...

Sorry for going off track...:cryyy:

Jerry

GoRdOn_B · May 23, 2010

i have mixed feelings about the rep because it is abused.. :thinking:
It it the cause for lots of drama, but it is also useful to find out who is a legitimate seller and who is a scammer. From what i remember (i might be wrong) is that the reb boosts were given to members who had high rep points from the old site. that was a looong time ago.
from what it sounds like is .. some thinking others is too high.. that just sounds like more drama.

I think we should just leave it alone or get rid of it.

c0ldshadow · May 23, 2010

k thx for feedback so far nothing will be done impulsively dont worry=)

just bringing the issue up b/c i did recv a bunch of msgs about it this week

maybe the best option would be for me to ask the ppl that complained what specific ppl they think have too high rep , with logical reason for why they didnt deserve it

jaycey · May 23, 2010

I think there should be the option to opt out of the rep system. Then the decent traders will show the rep they deserve and the bad traders will no doubt hide theirs.

All other rep is pretty pointless IMO

photonaholic · May 23, 2010

daguin said:
A gift, once given (deservedly or undeservedly) , becomes the property of the recipient.

Peace,
dave

charliebruce said:
I think it works fine as it is, to be honest - nobody's rep particularly stands out to me as too high for what they've contributed on here.

Couldn't agree more...

It's the reps that get tossed out by members during arguments that is really far more of an issue.

daguin · May 23, 2010

c0ldshadow said:
k thx for feedback so far nothing will be done impulsively dont worry=)

just bringing the issue up b/c i did recv a bunch of msgs about it this week

maybe the best option would be for me to ask the ppl that complained what specific ppl they think have too high rep , with logical reason for why they didnt deserve it

You might also consider if it is the same people who complained about it the last time we discussed this and maybe even if it is about the same people's rep.

As Lasersbee pointed out, we have already been through this.

"Sour grapes" do not make the wine sweeter.

photonaholic said:
Couldn't agree more...

It's the reps that get tossed out by members during arguments that is really far more of an issue.

If we can get the arguments squashed sooner, this problem should also be reduced

Peace,
dave

Cheech · May 23, 2010

Is there a thread about how rep works? All I know is that higher members rep is worth more( I think). I know rep means a lot to people for how many hours they've spent here. Maybe there should be some kind of troll rep indicator, Like flashing lights around someones avatar.
But personally I think rep should only come out of buy,sell,trade transactions. Reading around a little + post count will surely show you who the trusted minds around here are?
But I'm new so I'm probably wrong

daguin · May 23, 2010

Cheech said:
Is there a thread about how rep works? All I know is that higher members rep is worth more( I think). I know rep means a lot to people for how many hours they've spent here. Maybe there should be some kind of troll rep indicator, Like flashing lights around someones avatar.
But personally I think rep should only come out of buy,sell,trade transactions. Reading around a little + post count will surely show you who the trusted minds around here are?
But I'm new so I'm probably wrong

Always read at least the stickys in a forum

http://laserpointerforums.com/f59/basics-rep-system-40221.html

Peace,
dave

lasersbee · May 23, 2010

I think it might be fair to know WHO these 4 people are complaining
about and for WHAT reasons... and by WHOM... since this issue
is once again brought to the Forum Members about Forum Members
by Forum Members....

Jerry

Should all manually given reputation boosts be removed?

Should all manually given reputation boosts be removed, leaving only naturally rep?

Yes, remove manual boosts, but leave "naturally earned" rep

No, don't remove manual boosts, everything is OK

c0ldshadow

LPF Founder / Admin

lasersbee

0

daguin

0

charliebruce

0

lasersbee

0

mfo

0

SpikeD

0

lasersbee

0

GoRdOn_B

0

c0ldshadow

LPF Founder / Admin

jaycey

0

photonaholic

0

daguin

0

Cheech

0

daguin

0

lasersbee

0

Online statistics

Forum statistics

Share this page